Crops ›› 2021, Vol. 37 ›› Issue (3): 46-50.doi: 10.16035/j.issn.1001-7283.2021.03.007

Previous Articles     Next Articles

Application in Similarity-Difference Analysis Method on Evaluation of Grain Sorghum Hybrids

Qu Xiangchun(), Wang Nai, Shi Guishan, Yu Miao, Li Haiqing, Gao Yue, Xu Ning, Chen Bingru   

  1. Institute of Crop Germplasm Resources, Jilin Academy of Agricultural Sciences, Gongzhuling 136100, Jilin, China
  • Received:2020-07-27 Revised:2020-10-13 Online:2021-06-15 Published:2021-06-22

RichHTML

6

PDF (PC)

251

Abstract:

The similarity-difference analysis method was used to comprehensively analyze the eleven main traits of eleven sorghum hybrids registered in Jilin Academy of Agricultural Sciences from 2018 to 2020, including yield, growth period, plant height, panicle length, grain weight per spike and 1000-grain weight. According to the values of connection degree, the order of eleven hybrids was Jiza 225, Jiza 235, Jiza 236, Jiza 227, Jiza 224, Jiza 229, Jiza 228, Jiza 157, Jiza 149, Jiza 233, and Jiza 237. The results showed that this method could not only comprehensively and objectively evaluate sorghum hybrids, but also provide more information for the breeder to improve hybrids.

Key words: Sorghum, Hybrids, Main traits, Similarity-difference analysis method, Comprehensive evaluation

Table 1

The information of sorghum hybrids and genetic relationship of their parents"

杂交种
Hybrid		 登记年份
Registered year		 不育系
Sterile line		 恢复系
Restorer line		 细胞质类型
Cytoplasm type		 不育系亲缘
Relationship of sterile line		 恢复系亲缘
Relationship of restorer line
吉杂229 Jiza 229 2018 吉3199A 吉R209 A1 哲15B×吉2055B (南133×吉123R)×吉R9060
吉杂225 Jiza 225 2018 吉2255A 南133 A1 SX213B×吉2055B 忻粱52×VI494
吉杂224 Jiza 224 2019 吉5501A 吉3975R A1 白101B×吉2055B 南133×吉R10125
吉杂227 Jiza 227 2019 吉5502A 吉1233R A1 吉2055B×白203B (R123×南133)×吉 R9060
吉杂228 Jiza 228 2019 吉119A 吉1738R A1 (吉2055B×哲15B)×吉2055B 南133×吉R10125
吉杂233 Jiza 233 2019 吉5575A 吉2534R A1 吉2055B×L7050B 06H419×0-30
吉杂235 Jiza 235 2019 吉4285A 吉10125R A2 TAM428B×吉2055A (吉R9060×吉123R)×南133
吉杂236 Jiza 236 2019 吉303A 吉2178R A1 (吉2055B×97101B)×吉2055B (吉9060×吉123R×南133)×06H419R
吉杂237 Jiza 237 2020 3155A 吉2685R A1 哲15B×吉2055B 2115×南133
吉杂149 Jiza 149 2018 吉2055A 吉R9060 A1 314B×871300B 盘九七×奥红矮C42y×L116R
吉杂157 Jiza 157 2018 吉2055A 吉R126 A1 314B×871300B 吉R9060×吉R5062

Table 2

The information of 11 traits of hybrids, ideal values and weight coefficients of 11 hybrids"

杂交种
Hybrid		 产量
Yield
(kg/hm2)		 生育期
Growth
period
(d)		 株高
Plant
height
(cm)		 穗长
Panicle length
(cm)		 穗粒重
Grain weight per panicle (g)		 千粒重
1000-grain weight
(g)		 淀粉含量
Starch
content
(%)		 支链淀
粉含量
Amylopectin
content (%)		 粗蛋白含量
Protein
content
(%)		 单宁含量
Tannin
content
(%)		 接种发病率
Incidence of inoculation (%)
吉杂229
Jiza 229		 10180.5 118 140.0 28.5 77.5 27.9 77.1 81.6 8.8 1.2 15.7
吉杂225
Jiza 225		 10308.0 118 157.4 28.1 87.3 30.1 74.1 83.3 8.5 1.3 18.2
吉杂224
Jiza 224		 9456.0 120 150.7 29.0 94.7 29.3 76.9 77.5 8.2 1.4 9.6
吉杂227
Jiza 227		 9579.0 120 145.2 28.6 103.0 29.1 74.5 79.6 10.2 1.4 12.6
吉杂228
Jiza 228		 9145.5 118 150.3 27.6 94.7 30.5 76.8 78.1 8.4 1.3 12.6
吉杂233
Jiza 233		 8850.0 121 155.0 27.3 91.8 31.6 74.8 78.8 9.2 1.0 12.3
吉杂235
Jiza 235		 9591.0 120 160.0 29.3 95.8 31.5 76.7 76.4 9.0 1.5 11.9
吉杂236
Jiza 236		 9360.0 118 155.0 28.8 95.1 32.8 76.3 78.8 9.1 1.6 14.4
吉杂237
Jiza 237		 9196.5 117 145.0 31.2 77.0 27.8 75.1 80.2 8.4 1.6 11.9
吉杂149
Jiza 149		 10096.5 114 143.4 27.0 75.7 27.9 76.7 77.2 8.9 1.2 10.7
吉杂157
Jiza 157		 9303.0 119 150.5 30.0 81.5 29.0 79.9 73.2 9.0 1.2 13.8
平均Mean 9551.5 118 150.2 28.7 88.6 29.8 76.3 78.6 8.9 1.3 13.1
理想值
Ideal value		 10308.0 118.0 150.0 29.0 103.0 30.0 79.9 83.3 10.2 1.5 100.0
权重系数
Weight coefficient		 0.30 0.20 0.15 0.02 0.03 0.08 0.11 0.05 0.01 0.03 0.02

Table 3

Identical degrees of the real and ideal values of traits of 11 hybrids"

杂交种
Hybrid		 产量
Yield		 生育期
Growth
period		 株高
Plant
height		 穗长
Panicle
length		 穗粒重
Grain weight
per panicle		 千粒重
1000-grain
weight		 淀粉含量
Starch
content		 支链淀粉含量
Amylopectin
content		 粗蛋白含量
Protein
content		 单宁含量
Tannin
content		 接种发病率
Incidence of
inoculation
吉杂225
Jiza 225		 1.0000 1.0000 0.9530 0.9699 0.8476 0.9967 0.9274 1.0000 0.8333 0.8824 0.0549
吉杂224
Jiza 224		 0.9176 0.9833 0.9954 1.0000 0.9194 0.9772 0.9625 0.9304 0.8039 0.9375 0.1042
吉杂227
Jiza 227		 0.9295 0.9833 0.9690 0.9864 1.0000 0.9709 0.9324 0.9556 1.0000 0.9375 0.0794
吉杂228
Jiza 228		 0.8875 1.0000 0.9980 0.9539 0.9194 0.9836 0.9612 0.9376 0.8235 0.8824 0.0794
吉杂233
Jiza 233		 0.8588 0.9752 0.9677 0.9446 0.8913 0.9494 0.9362 0.9460 0.9020 0.7500 0.0813
杂交种
Hybrid		 产量
Yield		 生育期
Growth
period		 株高
Plant
height		 穗长
Panicle
length		 穗粒重
Grain weight
per panicle		 千粒重
1000-grain
weight		 淀粉含量
Starch
content		 支链淀粉含量
Amylopectin
content		 粗蛋白含量
Protein
content		 单宁含量
Tannin
content		 接种发病率
Incidence of
inoculation
吉杂235
Jiza 235		 0.9307 0.9833 0.9375 0.9898 0.9301 0.9524 0.9599 0.9172 0.8824 1.0000 0.0844
吉杂236
Jiza 236		 0.9083 1.0000 0.9677 0.9932 0.9233 0.9146 0.9549 0.9460 0.8922 0.9375 0.0697
吉杂237
Jiza 237		 0.8924 0.9916 0.9677 0.9295 0.7476 0.9317 0.9399 0.9628 0.8235 0.9375 0.0840
吉杂149
Jiza 149		 0.9798 0.9672 0.9579 0.9355 0.7350 0.9346 0.9599 0.9268 0.8725 0.8333 0.0935
吉杂157
Jiza 157		 0.9028 0.9916 0.9967 0.9667 0.7913 0.9677 1.0000 0.8788 0.8824 0.8333 0.0727
平均Mean 0.9268 0.9887 0.9680 0.9684 0.8598 0.9558 0.9545 0.9437 0.8708 0.8877 0.0788
标准差SD 0.0450 0.0112 0.0216 0.0245 0.0902 0.0255 0.0203 0.0322 0.0537 0.0710 0.0136
变异系数CV 0.0486 0.0113 0.0223 0.0253 0.1049 0.0267 0.0213 0.0342 0.0616 0.0800 0.1721

Table 4

Similarity-difference analysis of 11 sorghum hybrids"

杂交种
Hybrid		 综合同一度
Integrated identic degree		 差异度
Discrepant degree		 联系度
Connection degree		 同异分析排序
Similarity-difference analysis sorting
吉杂229 Jiza 229 0.9361 0.0639 0.8722 6
吉杂225 Jiza 225 0.9663 0.0337 0.9326 1
吉杂224 Jiza 224 0.9426 0.0574 0.8852 5
吉杂227 Jiza 227 0.9438 0.0562 0.8875 4
吉杂228 Jiza 228 0.9306 0.0694 0.8611 7
吉杂233 Jiza 233 0.9263 0.0737 0.8526 10
吉杂235 Jiza 235 0.9637 0.0363 0.9274 2
吉杂236 Jiza 236 0.9542 0.0458 0.9083 3
吉杂237 Jiza 237 0.9154 0.0846 0.8307 11
吉杂149 Jiza 149 0.9264 0.0736 0.8529 9
吉杂157 Jiza 157 0.9270 0.0730 0.8540 8
[1] 陈冰嬬, 李继洪, 王阳 , 等. 高粱[Sorghum bicolor(L.) Moench]种质资源研究进展. 西北农林科技大学学报(自然科学版), 2013(1):67-72,77.
[2] 高进, 蔡立旺, 蔡立旺 , 等. 甜高粱新品种(系)综合评价与聚类分析. 江苏农业科学, 2017,45(20):93-97.
[3] 张志, 杨亮, 高宇 . 春播晚熟高粱杂交种高产稳产性分析. 吉林农业科学, 2006,31(2):25-26,38.
[4] 桂松, 牛静, 胡建 . 中国高粱产业发展现状分析. 农业与技术, 2019,39(1):18-20.
[5] 郭瑞林, 杨春玲, 关立 , 等. 小麦品种区域试验的同异分析方法研究. 麦类作物学报, 2001,21(3):60-63.
[6] 郭瑞林 . 农业模糊学. 郑州: 河南科学技术出版社, 1991.
[7] 郭瑞林 . 作物灰色育种学. 北京: 中国农业科技出版社, 1995.
[8] 赵克勤 . 集对分析及其初步应用. 杭州: 浙江科学技术出版社, 2000.
[9] 宋志均, 韩勇, 薛鑫 , 等. 同异分析方法在小麦新品种(系)综合评价中的应用. 河南农业科学, 2011,40(1):33-36.
[10] 马洪文, 殷延勃, 张振海 . 同异分析法在水稻品种评价中的应用. 种子, 2002,1(1):64-65.
[11] 卢道文, 孙海潮, 芦连勇 , 等. 同异分析方法在玉米杂交种评价中的应用. 玉米科学, 2005,13(2):42-44.
[12] 雷全奎, 杨小兰, 郭建秋 , 等. 同异分析法对大豆新品系的综合评价. 园艺与种苗, 2020(1):40-42.
[13] 辽宁省农村经济委员会. 玉米高粱主要病害抗性鉴定技术规范:第4部分. DB 21/T 2219.1-2014. 沈阳: 辽宁省质量技术监督总局, 2014.
[14] 姜钰, 徐婧, 徐秀德 , 等. 高粱三系抗丝黑穗病鉴定与评价. 植物遗传资源学报, 2015,16(2):417-421.
[15] 郭瑞林, 刘亚飞, 吴秋芳 , 等. 小麦品种区域试验四种分析方法的比较研究. 麦类作物学报, 2011,31(4):776-779.
[16] 李嵩博, 唐朝臣, 陈峰 , 等. 中国粒用高粱改良品种的产量和品质性状时空变化. 中国农业科学, 2018,5(2):246-256.
[1] Gao Jie, Feng Guangcai, Li Xiaorong, Li Qingfeng, Wang Can, Zhang Guobing, Zhou Lengbo, Peng Qiu. Effects of Nitrogen Fertilizer on Yield and Nitrogen Use Characteristics in Waxy Sorghum Cultivar "Hongyingzi" [J]. Crops, 2021, 37(4): 118-122.
[2] Zhang Ruidong, Gao Mingyue, Yue Zhongxiao, Zhou Yufei, Cao xiong. Effects of Drought at Different Stages of Grain Filling Period on Starch Accumulation of Sorghum Grains [J]. Crops, 2021, 37(4): 172-177.
[3] Guo Qiang, Ma Wenqing, Qin Changxian, Shi Zesheng, Peng Chong, Bi Dejin, He Hongliang, Liang Yongjian, Tang Liqiu. Comprehensive Evaluation of New Sugarcane Clones by DTOPSIS Method [J]. Crops, 2021, 37(4): 32-37.
[4] Feng Yanfei, Yang Wei, Ren Guoxin, Deng Jie, Li Wenlong, Gao Shuren. Comprehensive Evaluation of Some Maize Hybrids in Heilongjiang Province [J]. Crops, 2021, 37(4): 46-50.
[5] Li Zilin, Lu Yachun, Zhao Leifeng, Fan Dongsheng, Wei Zhong, Zhou Wenliang, Huang Liguang, Huang Yang, Huang Jingpeng, Gu Xinquan, Nian Fuzhao. Comprehensive Evaluation of the Suitability of Tobacco Planting Soil Fertility in Jingxi City [J]. Crops, 2021, 37(3): 155-160.
[6] Cao Xiaoyan, Wu Ailian, Wang Jinsong, Dong Erwei, Jiao Xiaoyan. Effects of Nitrogen Fertilization on Yield, Quality and Nitrogen Utilization Efficiency of Sorghum [J]. Crops, 2021, 37(2): 108-115.
[7] Zhou Qilong. Grey Relational Grade Evaluation of 19 Oat Varieties Introduced in Ali of Tibet [J]. Crops, 2021, 37(1): 26-31.
[8] Wang Rui, Ping Jun′ai, Zhang Fuyao, Zhan Pengjie, Chu Jianqiang. Identification and Evaluation of Sorghum Breeding Resources for Barren Tolerance [J]. Crops, 2020, 36(6): 30-37.
[9] Gao Jie, Feng Guangcai, Li Xiaorong, Li Qingfeng, Peng Qiu. Phenotypic Diversity and Clustering Analysis of Sorghum Germplasm Resources in Different Regions of Guizhou Province [J]. Crops, 2020, 36(6): 54-60.
[10] Wu Weihua, Liu Jiayou, Yuan Liuzheng, Yan Haixia, Fu Jiafeng, Wang Huiqiang, Wang Rui, Li Teng, Liu Kang. Effects of High Temperature Stress at Booting Stage on Maize Hybrids [J]. Crops, 2020, 36(5): 59-64.
[11] Zhang Yang, Zhang Wei, Zhao Weijun, Shao Rongfeng, Wang Guan, Xue Dingding, Li Jinmei. Variety Screening and Study of Cultivation Technology for Forage Triticale Varieties Based on Principal Component and Grey Relation Analysis [J]. Crops, 2020, 36(3): 117-124.
[12] Shi Lijuan, Bai Wenbin, Cao Changlin, Gao Peng. Effects of Exogenous Selenium Application on Yield, Grain Selenium Content and Quality in Sorghum [J]. Crops, 2020, 36(3): 191-196.
[13] Zhao Xunchao,Xu Jingyu,Gai Shengnan,Wei Yulei,Xu Xiaoxuan,Ding Dong,Liu Meng,Zhang Jinjie,Shao Wenjing. Identification of Stearyl -ACP Desaturase Gene (SbSAD) Family and Their Expression Analysis at Different Developmental Stages in Sorghum [J]. Crops, 2020, 36(2): 20-27.
[14] Gao Jie,Li Qingfeng,Li Xiaorong,Feng Guangcai,Peng Qiu. Analysis of the Characteristics of Dry Matter Production and Light Energy Utilization of Waxy Sorghum Applied in Different Eras in Guizhou Province [J]. Crops, 2020, 36(1): 41-46.
[15] Fan Xinqi,Wang Haiyan,Nie Meng′en,Zhao Xingkui,Zhang Yizhong,Yang Huiyong,Zhang Xiaojuan,Liang Du,Duan Yonghong,Liu Qingshan. Effects of EMS Mutagenesis on Emergence and Agronomic Traits in Sorghum [J]. Crops, 2020, 36(1): 47-54.
Viewed
Full text


Abstract

Cited
  Shared   
  Discussed   
No Suggested Reading articles found!