Crops ›› 2022, Vol. 38 ›› Issue (6): 33-41.doi: 10.16035/j.issn.1001-7283.2022.06.005

Previous Articles     Next Articles

Comprehensive Evaluation of Phenotypic Traits and Classification of Maize Landraces in Hunan Province

Guo Huanle1(), Tang Bin1, Li Han1, Cao Zhongyang1, Zeng Qiang1, Liu Liangwu3, Chen Zhihui1,2()   

  1. 1Hunan Crops Research Institute, Changsha 410125, Hunan, China
    2Southern Regional Collaborative Innovation Center for Grain and Oil Crops, Changsha 410126, Hunan, China
    3Agricultural and Rural Bureau of Anxiang County, Anxiang 415600, Hunan, China
  • Received:2021-09-26 Revised:2022-10-12 Online:2022-12-15 Published:2022-12-21
  • Contact: Chen Zhihui E-mail:guole469@163.com;czhui2008@163.com

RichHTML

11

PDF (PC)

168

Abstract:

A total of 139 maize landraces in Hunan province were selected for field identification of phenotypic traits. The phenotypic diversity was analyzed, and cluster analysis and principal component analysis were used to classify groups and evaluate their phenotypes, respectively. The variation coefficients of different traits ranged from 6.5% to 175.0% with an average of 41.8%, and the genetic diversity indexes ranged from 1.119 to 2.086 with an average of 1.839. The results of principal component analysis of 14 agronomic traits showed that the cumulative contribution rate of six principal components was 81.7379%. Phenotypic data clustering revealed that all varieties were divided into three groups, and the three groups could be divided into three, two, and three subgroups, respectively. The hilly maize area of southern Hunan and the mountain maize area of western Hunan were the main areas of special maize, and the mountain maize area of western Hunan was also the area of excellent germplasm of common maize. According to the comprehensive performance of all landraces, 22 varieties with excellent performance were selected as elite breeding materials for research. The phenotypic diversity of Hunan maize landraces is abundant, and the excellent germplasms selected can be used as important resources for the innovative and utilization in Hunan province.

Key words: Maize, Landrace, Genetic diversity, Comprehensive evaluation

Table 1

Distribution of collection areas of maize landraces in Hunan province"

采集地Collecting location 品种数量Number of varieties
湘东、湘中丘陵玉米区Hilly maize area of eastern and central Hunan
安化县 3
茶陵县 2
洞口县 5
隆回县 11
平江县 2
新化县 7
湘南丘陵山地玉米区Hilly maize area of southern Hunan
常宁市 1
道县 3
桂东县 5
江华县 2
蓝山县 4
宁远县 1
汝城县 2
新田县 1
炎陵县 2
江永县
湘北洞庭湖平、丘、山玉米区
Dongting lake, hill, mountain maize area of northern Hunan
桃源县 5
临湘市 2
湘西山地玉米区Mountain maize area of western Hunan
保靖县 3
城步县 5
慈利县 2
凤凰县 5
古丈县 4
洪江市 1
龙山县 3
泸溪县 2
桑植县 7
石门县 26
新晃县 13
永顺县 1
沅陵县 6
张家界市 2
靖州县 1

Table 2

Phenotypic trait variation of maize landraces in Hunan province"

性状
Trait		 变异范围
Range of variation		 均值
Mean		 变异系数
Variable coefficient (%)		 遗传多样性指数
Genetic diversity index
生育期Growth period (d) 85.0~119.0 97.8 6.5 1.943
株高Plant height (cm) 173.2~380.2 283.1 17.0 2.086
穗位高Ear height (cm) 50.5~227.5 133.3 27.1 1.814
叶片数Leaf number 15.5~25.0 19.4 11.1 2.043
空秆率Empty bar rate (%) 0.0~40.5 3.5 175.0 1.393
倒伏（折）率Lodging rate (%) 0.0~46.5 4.4 148.8 1.531
穗长Ear length (cm) 10.3~23.3 17.5 14.2 2.053
秃尖长Bald tip length (cm) 0.0~3.0 0.9 76.2 1.889
穗粗Ear diameter (cm) 1.0~5.3 4.3 13.7 1.845
穗行数Row number per ear 9.5~16.5 12.9 10.4 2.048
行粒数Grain number per row 15.0~44.8 33.8 17.3 2.032
单株产量Yield per plant (g) 18.4~177.5 109.1 31.6 2.067
出籽率Rate of seed (%) 49.7~88.6 80.6 6.9 1.760
千粒重1000-grain weight (g) 74.0~449.0 284.6 23.7 1.968
籽粒颜色数Number of grain colors 1.0~4.0 1.8 47.4 1.119

Table 3

Comparison of maize landraces traits in different ecological regions in Hunan province"

性状
Trait		 统计
Statistics		 湘东、湘中丘陵玉米区
Hilly maize area in eastern
and central Hunan		 湘南丘陵山地玉米区
Hilly maize area
of southern Hunan		 湘北洞庭湖平、丘、山玉米区
Dongting lake, hill, mountain
maize area of northern Hunan		 湘西山地玉米区
Mountain maize area
of western Hunan
生育期
Growth period (d)		 范围 91.0~110.0 86.0~119.0 96.0~114.0 85.0~111.0
均值 96.9 101.8 99.9 96.9
变异系数 (%) 5.6 10.4 6.4 4.8
株高
Plant height (cm)		 范围 180.0~328.5 195.0~380.2 259.5~345.5 173.2~375.4
均值 226.3 291.0 303.3 285.6
变异系数 (%) 16.1 19.6 10.0 16.7
穗位高
Ear height (cm)		 范围 50.5~186.3 59.0~227.5 115.0~206.7 51.3~220.0
均值 121.8 146.8 150.9 132.6
变异系数 (%) 25.4 28.1 23.5 26.8
叶片数
Leaf number		 范围 15.5~23.5 15.5~25.0 17~24.0 15.5~24.0
均值 19.0 20.3 19.9 19.2
变异系数 (%) 11.4 12.1 10.8 10.5
空秆率
Empty bar rate (%)		 范围 0.0~9.6 0.0~40.5 0.0~2.6 0.0~25.3
均值 1.9 9.3 0.9 2.8
变异系数 (%) 146.4 129.7 130.2 135.6
倒伏（折）率
Lodging rate (%)		 范围 0.0~18.7 0.0~20.0 0.0~46.5 0.0~19.1
均值 3.6 7.1 11.8 3.2
变异系数 (%) 147.1 108.9 133.7 139.3
性状
Trait		 统计
Statistics		 湘东、湘中丘陵玉米区
Hilly maize area in eastern
and central Hunan		 湘南丘陵山地玉米区
Hilly maize area
of southern Hunan		 湘北洞庭湖平、丘、山玉米区
Dongting lake, hill, mountain
maize area of northern Hunan		 湘西山地玉米区
Mountain maize area
of western Hunan
穗长
Ear length (cm)		 范围 10.4~22.5 13.8~21.4 14.5~21.3 10.3~23.3
均值 16.8 17.5 17.9 17.8
变异系数 (%) 16.5 11.7 12.1 14.1
秃尖长
Bald tip length (cm)		 范围 0.2~2.5 0.0~1.6 0.0~2.8 0.0~3.0
均值 1.0 0.7 1.8 0.9
变异系数 (%) 63.8 59.2 50.7 82.1
穗粗
Ear diameter (cm)		 范围 3.6~5.1 1.0~5.0 4.0~5.0 1.0~5.3
均值 4.3 3.9 4.5 4.4
变异系数 (%) 10.9 20.6 10.2 12.3
穗行数
Row number per ear		 范围 9.8~15.5 10.5~16.0 11.0~14.0 9.5~16.5
均值 13.0 13.3 12.5 12.8
变异系数 (%) 9.8 10.7 9.8 10.6
行粒数
Grain number per row		 范围 18.5~40.1 22.3~42.3 27.5~40.0 15.0~44.8
均值 30.5 33.0 33.5 35.3
变异系数 (%) 19.8 15.0 12.2 16.0
单株产量
Yield per plant (g)		 范围 50.5~156.5 27.5~146.5 71.7~139 18.4~239.0
均值 104.6 83.9 103.0 119.1
变异系数 (%) 30.3 42.1 21.4 29.8
出籽率
Rate of seed (%)		 范围 73.9~87.3 49.7~86.3 74.0~85.3 56.2~88.6
均值 81.7 77.8 80.5 80.9
变异系数 (%) 4.3 12.1 5.0 5.9
千粒重
1000-grain weight (g)		 范围 241.5~449.0 74.0~369.4 210.8~377.2 77.9~421.5
均值 301.9 222.7 293.6 293.4
变异系数 (%) 18.4 37.6 17.7 20.3
株型比例（披散型:中间型:紧凑型）
Ratio of plant type (horizontal:
middle:compact)		 14:14:2 7:14:0 2:4:1 21:60:0
籽粒类型Grain type 多硬粒型 多硬粒或爆裂型 多硬粒型 多硬粒和中间型
籽粒颜色Grain color 多黄粒或黄白粒 白粒或黄粒 白粒或黄粒 多白粒或黄白粒
穗轴颜色Cob color 多白色或红白兼有 多为白色 白色 多为白色

Table 4

Principal component analysis of phenotypic traits of maize landraces in Hunan province"

性状
Trait		 第1主成分
PC1		 第2主成分
PC2		 第3主成分
PC3		 第4主成分
PC4		 第5主成分
PC5		 第6主成分
PC6
单株产量Yield per plant 0.3597 0.3400 -0.0137 0.0005 -0.0801 0.1904
生育期Growth period 0.1320 -0.2914 0.2288 -0.4853 0.0749 0.0619
株高Plant height 0.4368 -0.169 0.0290 -0.0161 0.1238 -0.1375
穗位高Ear height 0.3656 -0.3386 -0.0303 0.1467 0.0688 0.1850
穗位比Ratio of ear height 0.1392 -0.3721 -0.0934 0.2747 -0.0100 0.4624
倒伏（折）率Lodging rate 0.1168 -0.2452 -0.2661 0.3365 0.0774 -0.1196
叶片数Leaf number 0.3191 -0.2558 0.1587 -0.1469 0.0031 0.1409
穗长Ear length 0.3905 0.1350 -0.1522 0.0371 -0.0852 -0.4666
秃尖长Bald tip length -0.0169 0.0420 0.3813 0.5618 0.5349 -0.2421
穗粗Ear diameter 0.2663 0.3003 0.3950 0.0191 0.0383 0.0281
穗行数Row number per ear 0.0229 -0.0154 0.5850 0.2672 -0.6509 0.0509
行粒数Grain number per row 0.3735 0.2150 -0.2927 0.0227 -0.2531 -0.1812
出籽率Rate of seed 0.0068 0.3313 -0.2608 0.2998 -0.0534 0.4993
千粒重1000-grain weight 0.1738 0.3547 0.1432 -0.2309 0.4201 0.3115
特征值Eigenvalue 3.6407 3.3966 1.3140 1.1702 0.9752 0.9467
贡献率Contribution rate (%) 26.0047 24.2611 9.3856 8.3589 6.9654 6.7622
累计贡献率Cumulative contribution rate (%) 26.0047 50.2659 59.6515 68.0103 74.9757 81.7379

Fig.1

Clustering diagram of phenotypic traits of maize landraces in Hunan province"

Table 5

Phenotypic comparison of different groups of maize landraces in Hunan province"

性状
Trait		 统计
Statistics		 种质类群Germplasm group
Ⅰ Ⅱ Ⅲ
生育期
Growth
period (d)		 范围 85.0~111.0 87.0~119.0 86.0~114.0
均值 96.4 106.3 97.5
变异系数 (%) 6.2 9.1 4.9
株高
Plant height
(cm)		 范围 173.2~345.5 212.0~380.2 231.4~375.4
均值 250.2 295.1 308.7
变异系数 (%) 15.3 20.7 11.4
穗位高
Ear height
(cm)		 范围 50.5~180.2 103.5~227.5 93.5~220.0
均值 109.6 163.1 148.1
变异系数 (%) 25.9 20.5 20.7
叶片数
Leaf
number		 范围 15.5~22.5 15.5~25.0 15.6~24.0
均值 18.3 20.5 20.1
变异系数 (%) 9.7 13.4 9.5
空秆率
Empty bar
rate (%)		 范围 0.0~25.3 0.0~40.5 0.0~12.5
均值 2.3 13.6 2.7
变异系数 (%) 171.7 107.1 105.4
倒伏（折）率
Lodging
rate (%)		 范围 0.0~46.5 0.0~20.0 0.0~19.1
均值 3.2 12.0 4.1
变异系数 (%) 217.6 60.3 125.1
穗长
Ear length
(cm)		 范围 10.4~20.8 10.3~18.5 14.3~23.3
均值 16.6 15.9 18.6
变异系数 (%) 13.6 16.4 11.8
秃尖长
Bald tip
length (cm)		 范围 0.0~2.8 0.0~1.2 0.0~3
均值 0.9 0.7 1.0
变异系数 (%) 81.8 63.1 71.5
穗粗
Ear diameter
(cm)		 范围 3.6~5.0 1.0~4.8 3.8~5.3
均值 4.3 3.3 4.6
变异系数 (%) 9.5 35.0 7.7
穗行数
Row number
per ear		 范围 9.5~15.5 10.0~16.0 10.0~16.5
均值 12.8 13.7 12.8
变异系数 (%) 11.2 11.5 9.2
行粒数
Grain number
per row		 范围 18.5~43.4 15.0~37.5 24.0~44.8
均值 31.4 28.8 36.8
变异系数 (%) 17.3 21.0 12.2
单株产量
Yield per
plant (g)		 范围 55.1~165.3 18.4~89.0 50.5~239.0
均值 100.3 50.5 128.2
变异系数 (%) 26.7 41.7 23.8
出籽率
Rate of
seed (%)		 范围 69.8~88.6 49.7~86.3 72.4~87.3
均值 81.7 72.2 81.1
变异系数 (%) 4.6 16.7 4.5
千粒重
1000-grain
weight (g)		 范围 180.7~449.0 74.0~216.4 210.8~421.5
均值 289.1 131.9 307.3
变异系数 (%) 18.6 32.7 13.9
株型比例（披散型:
中间型:紧凑型）
Ratio of plant type (horizontal:
middle:compact)		 25:30:3 7:5:0 12:57:0
籽粒类型Grain type
 多为硬粒
 爆裂型或
硬粒型		 多为中间型
籽粒颜色Grain color 多为黄色 黄色或白色 多为白色
穗轴颜色Cob color 多为白色 白色 多为白色

Table 6

Comprehensive score of 20 excellent common maize landraces"

品种编号
No. of variety		 主成分Principal component F值
F-value
PC1 PC2 PC3 PC4 PC5 PC6
DZ135 343.6013 113.6271 72.9908 -112.5085 209.3325 185.4268 173.0979
DZ67 332.8456 122.2514 64.7669 -111.8553 190.3193 179.3555 169.2358
DZ134 345.7635 94.7997 61.3455 -98.3402 193.5521 182.1241 166.6912
DZ62 380.6232 60.4498 51.7283 -81.5386 183.7027 166.1347 166.0378
DZ94 373.6781 63.6568 55.3201 -81.6482 179.9213 162.0007 164.5171
DZ63 322.3727 121.0311 56.0225 -99.4880 179.7242 170.8240 164.1935
DZ1 361.8462 77.6879 49.4397 -77.7813 169.8443 160.8843 163.6865
DZ46 376.8022 64.4331 44.7874 -77.7325 172.7126 149.9089 163.3178
DZ21 372.8196 67.8220 47.1401 -70.5197 157.8048 155.5824 163.2633
DZ23 306.0431 125.5199 63.0686 -100.0632 176.4869 175.9020 161.2251
DZ69 328.3368 102.9784 50.4664 -88.9590 162.8725 159.8348 158.8261
DZ17 364.4088 61.4415 51.0730 -80.5892 167.0578 151.6977 158.5826
DZ44 341.9059 85.9354 50.0632 -82.3584 166.3171 152.1531 158.3712
DZ11 375.9578 43.3966 55.1385 -80.5772 180.1901 148.9178 158.2580
DZ74 368.4507 51.5870 49.7368 -78.1330 164.0384 149.2503 156.5815
DZ49 368.6057 55.9029 43.7244 -74.9902 159.9974 131.5052 155.7304
DZ16 358.6365 57.2472 46.5358 -73.2033 164.2240 150.9514 155.4322
DZ56 340.6675 73.9790 52.5015 -82.8216 171.2333 156.3854 155.4300
DZ71 383.6510 32.8193 43.9965 -65.4249 156.6837 142.9854 155.3422
DZ139 307.0992 106.5830 65.2927 -107.0566 177.9810 168.4063 154.9878
[1] 佟屏亚. 中国玉米种质资源的整理与成就. 中国种业, 2001(3):7-8.
[2] 刘纪麟. 玉米育种学(第二版). 北京: 中国农业出版社, 2001:152-155.
[3] Li Y, Shi Y S, Wang T Y. Establishment of a core collection for maize germplasm preserved in Chinese National Genebank using geographic distribution and characterization data. Genetic Resources and Crop Evolution, 2004, 51:845-852.
doi: 10.1007/s10722-005-8313-8
[4] Li Y, Shi Y S, Wang T Y. A phenotypic diversity analysis of maize germplasm preserved in China. Maydica, 2002, 47:107-114.
[5] 刘志斋, 郭荣华, 石云素, 等. 中国玉米地方品种核心种质花期相关性的表型多样性研究. 中国农业科学, 2008, 41(6):1591-1602.
[6] 蔡一林, 刘志斋, 王天宇, 等. 国内部分玉米地方品种的品质与农艺性状的表型多样性分析. 植物遗传资源学报, 2011, 12(1):31-36.
[7] 郭荣华. 我国南方区玉米地方品种遗传多样性研究与群体结构分析. 成都: 四川农业大学, 2008.
[8] 吴元奇, 郑灵, 荣廷昭. 西南地区白玉米地方种质资源分布及遗传多样性. 草业学报, 2013, 22(4):160-169.
[9] 贾瑞玲, 赵小琴, 南铭, 等. 64 份苦荞种质资源农艺性状遗传多样性分析与综合评价. 作物杂志, 2021(3):19-27.
[10] 陈彦惠, 张世煌, 吴连成, 等. 中国主要玉米改良群体杂种优势模式的初步评价. 华北农学报, 2002, 17(4):30-36.
doi: 10.3321/j.issn:1000-7091.2002.04.008
[11] 陈彦惠, 王利明, 戴景瑞. 中国温带玉米种质与热带、亚热带种质杂优组合模式研究. 作物学报, 2000, 26(5):557-564.
[12] 李新海, 李明顺, 袁立行, 等. 热带、亚热带种质的研究与利用. 中国农业科学, 2000, 33(增刊):20-26.
[13] 陈泽辉, 高翔, 祝云芳. Suwan与我国四大玉米种质配合力和杂种优势的分析. 玉米科学, 2005, 13(1):5-9.
[14] 潘光堂, 杨克诚, 李晚忱, 等. 我国西南玉米杂种优势群及其杂优模式研究与应用的回顾. 玉米科学, 2020, 28(1):1-8.
[1] Zhang Dongxia, Qin Anzhen. Relationships among Crop Evapotranspiration, Soil Moisture and Temperature in Winter Wheat-Summer Maize Cropping System [J]. Crops, 2022, 38(6): 145-151.
[2] Qiao Jiangfang, Zhang Panpan, Shao Yunhui, Liu Jingbao, Li Chuan, Zhang Meiwei, Huang Lu. Effects of Different Planting Densities and Varieties on Dry Matter Production and Yield Components of Summer Maize [J]. Crops, 2022, 38(6): 186-192.
[3] Li Wangsheng, Wang Xueqian, Yin Xilong, Shi Yang, Liu Dali, Tan Wenbo, Xing Wang. Comprehensive Evaluation of Drought Tolerance of Sugar Beet Germplasms at Seedling Stage [J]. Crops, 2022, 38(6): 54-60.
[4] Zhao Xiaoqin, Jia Ruiling, Liu Junxiu, Liu Yanming, Wen Yinhua, Shi Lili, Zhang Juanning, Ma Ning. Agronomic Traits and Genetic Diversity Analysis of 120 Foxtail Millet Germplasms [J]. Crops, 2022, 38(6): 61-69.
[5] Xu Chuangye, Zhang Jianjun, Zhou Gang, Zhang Kaipeng, Zhu Xiaohui, Wang Jiaxi, Dang Yi, Zhao Gang, Wang Lei, Li Shangzhong, Fan Tinglu. Screening and Evaluation of New Maize Varieties with Compact Planting, High Yield and Suitable for Mechanical Grain Harvest in Loess Plateau in Eastern Gansu Province [J]. Crops, 2022, 38(5): 104-110.
[6] Li Long, Xiao Rang, Zhang Yongling. Effects of Combined Application of Nitrogen, Phosphorus and Potassium on Seed Maize Yield and Economic Benefit [J]. Crops, 2022, 38(5): 111-117.
[7] Li Yanlu, Wang Junpeng, Yu Xinzhi, Wei Honglei, Chen Qiyu, Zhao Hongxiang, Xu Chen, Bian Shaofeng, Zhang Zhian. Effects of Mulching Different Plastic Films on Accumulation and Distribution of Dry Matter and Nitrogen in Maize in Cold and Cool Areas [J]. Crops, 2022, 38(5): 124-129.
[8] Zhang Jianye, Du Qingzhi, Liu Xiang, Deng Jiahui, Jiao Qin, Gong Luo, Jiang Xingyin. The Effects of S-ABA on Germination and Growth of Maize under Salt-Alkali Stress [J]. Crops, 2022, 38(5): 167-173.
[9] Zhou Chao, Zhang Tiantian, Yang Li’na, Zhang Yong, Ma Chong, Dai Weicheng, Wu Cuixia, Song Min. Systemic Distribution of Flonicamid in Maize and Its Activity Effect against Rhopalosiphum maidis with Root Absorption [J]. Crops, 2022, 38(5): 261-266.
[10] Duan Mengran, Liu Fengze, Ge Jianrong, Yi Hongmei, Yang Hongming, Gao Yuqian, Yue Pengwu, Ma Wenyu, Ban Xiuli, Wang Fengge. Purity Identification of SSR Molecular Markers for Main Maize Varieties in Jilin Province [J]. Crops, 2022, 38(5): 34-41.
[11] Hou Jingjing, Jin Fang, Zhao Li, Wang Bin. Comprehensive Evaluation of Agronomic and Quality Traits of 16 New Oil Flax Lines [J]. Crops, 2022, 38(5): 42-48.
[12] Zhu Hang, Cui Fangqing, Lu Chuanli, Chen Weiwei, Li Xuhui, Lu Siqi, Zhang Xiangbo, Zhao Hua, Qi Yongwen. Analysis of Carotenoid Content in Maize Inbred Lines with Different Color Grains [J]. Crops, 2022, 38(5): 62-68.
[13] Wang Yuanyuan, Gu Zihan, Chen Pingping, Yi Zhenxie. Study on Feasibility of Seasonal Substituted Planting of Maize to Rice in Cd Contaminated Paddy Field [J]. Crops, 2022, 38(4): 187-192.
[14] Lü Jianzhen, Ren Ying, Wang Hongyong, Zhang Tingjun, Ma Jianping, Zhao Kai. Comprehensive Phenotype Evaluation of 264 Major Foxtail Millet Bred Varieties (Lines) [J]. Crops, 2022, 38(4): 22-31.
[15] Wang Jiabao, Ji Huaiyuan, Mei Jiafa, Tao Zhiguo, Shu Zhifeng, Jiang Sanqiao. The Breeding of New Maize Variety Quankeyu 900 and Its Cultivation, Seed Production Techniques [J]. Crops, 2022, 38(4): 267-270.
Viewed
Full text


Abstract

Cited
  Shared   
  Discussed   
No Suggested Reading articles found!