Crops ›› 2021, Vol. 37 ›› Issue (4): 46-50.doi: 10.16035/j.issn.1001-7283.2021.04.007

Previous Articles     Next Articles

Comprehensive Evaluation of Some Maize Hybrids in Heilongjiang Province

Feng Yanfei(), Yang Wei, Ren Guoxin, Deng Jie, Li Wenlong, Gao Shuren()   

  1. College of Agriculture, Heilongjiang Bayi Agricultural University/Heilongjiang Provincial Key Laboratory of Modern Agricultural Cultivation Technology and Crop Germplasm Improvement, Daqing 163319, Heilongjiang, China
  • Received:2021-01-23 Revised:2021-05-13 Online:2021-08-15 Published:2021-08-13
  • Contact: Gao Shuren E-mail:F2022973046@163.com;gaoshr107@126.com

RichHTML

6

PDF (PC)

343

Abstract:

Comprehensive evaluation of maize hybrids are an important basis for the breeding, certification, and popularization of new varieties. In this experiment, some maize hybrids planted in Heilongjiang province were used as experimental materials. Eight characteristics were measured such as yield (14% water content), grain water content, unit weight, bald tip length, cone rate of seed, axle diameter/ear diameter, 100-grain weight, and ear length using the grey correlation method to evaluate the tested 28 maize hybrids. The results showed that the first three of the weighted correlation degree of maize hybrids were Demeiya 3, Xianyu 696 and Xianyu 335, which had the excellent comprehensive performance.

Key words: Maize, Grey relational grade, Comprehensive evaluation

Table 1

The statistic weight of the agronomic traits"

项目Item X1 X2 X3 X4 X5 X6 X7 X8
权重系数
Weight coefficient (Wk)		 0.30 0.15 0.15 0.10 0.10 0.10 0.05 0.05

Table 2

The F-values of agronomic traits among hybrids"

项目Item X1 X2 X3 X4 X5 X6 X7 X8
F值F-value 1.85** 1.85** 3.70** 4.70** 2.71** 10.93** 2.05** 2.07**

Table 3

The agronomic traits of tested materials"

杂交种Hybrid X1 (kg) X2 (%) X3 (g/L) X4 (cm) X5 (%) X6 X7 (g) X8 (cm)
理想品种Ideal variety 7.75 23.42 711.67 0.47 89.49 0.47 45.10 27.10
中单103 Zhongdan 103 5.81 29.29 613.33 2.65 81.89 0.54 35.27 23.42
中试6323 Zhongshi 6323 7.18 32.60 620.50 1.51 85.98 0.58 39.36 27.10
先玉335 Xianyu 335 6.69 30.41 655.00 1.13 82.49 0.51 38.03 25.88
龙214 Long 214 5.61 31.68 636.67 0.92 77.37 0.51 30.77 22.21
誉成1号Yucheng 1 5.25 35.82 639.33 1.26 79.01 0.57 41.17 24.74
先玉696 Xianyu 696 7.75 32.27 644.67 0.83 82.32 0.49 42.15 25.63
ZH08 5.47 32.58 645.33 2.19 75.07 0.62 39.96 22.53
ZH04 6.51 33.42 633.33 1.66 84.35 0.58 33.01 23.69
ZH02 4.32 34.28 621.33 1.74 78.22 0.71 30.72 22.56
ZH01 5.74 30.83 633.33 1.03 89.49 0.71 35.28 23.51
龙单81 Longdan 81 6.70 32.62 634.67 1.05 75.84 0.78 45.10 25.45
龙313 Long 313 6.46 31.97 603.67 2.04 79.98 0.55 35.57 23.25
鑫鑫1号Xinxin 1 5.66 32.68 639.67 1.90 79.28 0.76 41.11 26.85
龙410 Long 410 5.75 31.73 620.33 1.59 79.94 0.54 39.90 22.47
杂交种Hybrid X1 (kg) X2 (%) X3 (g/L) X4 (cm) X5 (%) X6 X7 (g) X8 (cm)
东265 Dong 265 5.02 30.22 658.00 1.86 81.55 0.54 43.22 24.83
黑283 Hei 283 6.70 30.90 629.00 1.58 79.85 0.58 37.15 23.42
黑285 Hei 285 5.82 32.72 636.00 1.20 79.87 0.56 40.18 25.02
垦单10 Kendan 10 6.24 30.08 645.00 2.11 80.13 0.61 38.32 24.00
东266 Dong 266 5.02 32.44 629.67 2.11 85.60 0.47 29.81 21.08
黑3104 Hei 3104 5.94 30.04 671.67 1.30 83.22 0.52 35.98 23.17
德美亚3号Demeiya 3 6.07 25.48 658.33 0.47 82.92 0.55 41.53 24.51
克334 Ke 334 4.88 25.90 673.50 3.23 86.69 0.65 35.40 24.25
克436 Ke 436 6.11 26.43 653.00 2.22 81.26 0.61 41.61 26.21
克玉15 Keyu 15 5.72 26.30 659.00 1.39 81.78 0.56 33.12 22.45
克044 Ke 044 4.77 24.84 690.67 2.01 80.31 0.58 36.95 23.69
德美亚1号Demeiya 1 5.01 23.42 711.67 1.13 83.54 0.56 31.86 21.78
东1412 Dong 1412 6.03 29.73 614.33 2.07 70.35 0.55 31.90 23.93
龙辐玉5号Longfuyu 5 4.67 32.64 607.33 2.11 65.25 0.62 34.04 22.49

Table 4

The correlation coefficients of agronomic traits between tested varieties and ideal variety"

杂交种Hybrid X1 X2 X3 X4 X5 X6 X7 X8
中单103 Zhongdan 103 0.9214 0.9214 0.9551 0.3876 0.9719 0.9517 0.9309 0.9558
中试6323 Zhongshi 6323 0.9756 0.8822 0.9582 0.5702 0.9868 0.9262 0.9585 1.0000
先玉335 Xianyu 335 0.9555 0.9077 0.9736 0.6765 0.9741 0.9718 0.9493 0.9849
龙214 Long 214 0.9140 0.8928 0.9654 0.7541 0.9559 0.9718 0.9024 0.9421
誉成1号Yucheng 1 0.9010 0.8472 0.9665 0.6359 0.9616 0.9324 0.9712 0.9712
先玉696 Xianyu 696 1.0000 0.8860 0.9689 0.7931 0.9734 0.9857 0.9782 0.9819
ZH08 0.9089 0.8825 0.9692 0.4452 0.9480 0.9020 0.9626 0.9457
ZH04 0.9483 0.8730 0.9639 0.5370 0.9808 0.9262 0.9163 0.9589
ZH02 0.8690 0.8636 0.9586 0.5208 0.9589 0.8519 0.9020 0.9460
ZH01 0.9188 0.9027 0.9639 0.7113 1.0000 0.8519 0.9310 0.9568
龙单81 Longdan 81 0.9559 0.8820 0.9645 0.7041 0.9506 0.8166 1.0000 0.9797
龙313 Long 313 0.9464 0.8894 0.9509 0.4678 0.9651 0.9452 0.9329 0.9538
鑫鑫1号 Xinxin 1 0.9159 0.8813 0.9667 0.4911 0.9626 0.8263 0.9708 0.9969
龙410 Long 410 0.9192 0.8922 0.9581 0.5520 0.9649 0.9517 0.9622 0.9450
东265 Dong 265 0.8929 0.9100 0.9750 0.4982 0.9707 0.9517 0.9860 0.9723
黑283 Hei 283 0.9559 0.9019 0.9619 0.5542 0.9646 0.9262 0.9434 0.9558
黑285 Hei 285 0.9218 0.8809 0.9651 0.6540 0.9647 0.9388 0.9642 0.9745
垦单10 Kendan 10 0.9378 0.9117 0.9691 0.4570 0.9656 0.9079 0.9513 0.9625
东266 Dong 266 0.8929 0.8840 0.9622 0.4570 0.9854 1.0000 0.8965 0.9297
黑3104 Hei 3104 0.9263 0.9122 0.9812 0.6244 0.9767 0.9650 0.9356 0.9529
德美亚3号Demeiya 3 0.9312 0.9709 0.9751 1.0000 0.9756 0.9452 0.9737 0.9685
克334 Ke 334 0.8880 0.9652 0.9821 0.3333 0.9895 0.8846 0.9317 0.9654
克436 Ke 436 0.9328 0.9581 0.9727 0.4409 0.9696 0.9079 0.9743 0.9889
克玉15 Keyu 15 0.9181 0.9598 0.9754 0.6000 0.9715 0.9388 0.9170 0.9448
克044 Ke 044 0.8842 0.9798 0.9901 0.4726 0.9662 0.9262 0.9420 0.9589
德美亚1号Demeiya 1 0.8925 1.0000 1.0000 0.6765 0.9779 0.9388 0.9091 0.9373
东1412 Dong 1412 0.9297 0.9160 0.9555 0.4631 0.9321 0.9452 0.9094 0.9617
龙辐玉5号Longfuyu 5 0.8808 0.8818 0.9524 0.4570 0.9155 0.9020 0.9229 0.9452

Table 5

The comprehensive evaluation values of varieties"

杂交种
Hybrid		 加权关联度
Weighted correlation value		 排名
Ranking
德美亚3号Demeiya 3 0.9605 1
先玉696 Xianyu 696 0.9515 2
先玉335 Xianyu 335 0.9278 3
德美亚1号Demeiya 1 0.9194 4
中试6323 Zhongshi 6323 0.9150 5
龙214 Long 214 0.9133 6
黑3104 Hei 3104 0.9129 7
克玉15 Keyu 15 0.9098 8
龙单81 Longdan 81 0.9098 9
ZH01 0.9063 10
黑285 Hei 285 0.9061 11
黑283 Hei 283 0.9058 12
克436 Ke 436 0.8994 13
ZH04 0.8982 14
龙410 Long 410 0.8955 15
誉成1号Yucheng 1 0.8925 16
克044 Ke 044 0.8923 17
垦单10 Kendan 10 0.8922 18
龙313 Long 313 0.8921 19
东农265 Dongnong 265 0.8906 20
东农1412 Dongnong 1412 0.8872 21
中单103 Zhongdan103 0.8834 22
东农266 Dongnong 266 0.8803 23
鑫鑫1号Xinxin 1 0.8784 24
ZH08 0.8754 25
克334 Ke 334 0.8741 26
龙辐玉5号Longfuyu 5 0.8602 27
ZH02 0.8596 28
[1] 张铁强, 王翊, 王任杰, 等. 黑龙江垦区玉米种植概况. 东北农业大学学报, 2017(18):38-41.
[2] 马锐, 王晓军, 李华芝, 等. 黑龙江省主要粮食作物种植面积与产量变化分析. 黑龙江农业科学, 2020,314(8):96-101.
[3] 杨引福, 李立坤, 郭强, 等. 灰色综合评价在玉米新品种评价中的应用. 农业科技通讯, 2008(4):84-89.
[4] 高忠江, 施树良, 李钰. SPSS方差分析在生物统计的应用. 现代生物医学进展, 2008,8(11):2116-2120.
[5] 高志军, 侯建华, 刘玉爱, 等. 玉米杂交种的灰色关联度分析. 内蒙古农业大学学报, 2007,28(2):128-131.
[6] 倪正斌, 孙扣忠, 孙红芹, 等. 玉米杂交种产量与主要农艺性状的灰色关联度分析. 金陵科技学院学报, 2017,33(2):65-69.
[7] 郑国栋, 黄金堂, 陈海玲. 花生产量与主要农艺性状之间的灰色关联度分析. 安徽农学通报, 2013(16):22-24.
[8] 赵倩, 刘兆晔, 刘春蕾, 等. 小麦新品种(系)的灰色关联度分析. 中国农学通报, 2007,23(9):259-262.
[9] 卓德众, 刘启华, 郭红甫. 灰色关联度分析法在玉米育种中的应用. 玉米科学, 1996,4(3):31-34.
[10] 郭晓霞, 郭玲玲, 王凤莲, 等. 籽粒性状对玉米产量和机收的影响研究进展. 现代农业科技, 2020(2):4-5,7.
[11] 柏流芳, 吕黄珍, 朱大洲, 等. 农作物育种中的综合评判方法. 农业工程, 2013(3):112-119.
[12] 解松峰, 谢世学, 张百忍, 等. 秦巴山区玉米杂交组合主要性状与产量间的灰色关联度分析. 作物杂志, 2012(1):52-57.
[13] 赵激. 灰色关联分析法在杂交玉米组合综合评判中的应用研究. 作物研究, 2002,16(4):178-180.
[14] 宫万明, 何文安, 邓少华, 等. 玉米杂交种主要农艺性状的灰色关联度分析及综合评价. 吉林农业科学, 2006,31(3):7-10.
[15] 王黎明, 唐道廷, 刘必善 等. 灰色关联度分析在湖北省玉米杂交种综合评价中的应用. 湖北农业科学, 2008,47(4):391-393.
[16] 宋继娟, 柳金来, 周柏明, 等. 玉米穗部性状与产量关系的研究. 吉林农业科学, 2006,31(4):11-13.
[17] 邓杰, 孙丽芳, 王霞, 等. 玉米收获期籽粒含水量与穗部性状的关联分析. 种子, 2019,38(10):93-96.
[18] 车海先, 李海玉. 玉米容重影响因素浅析. 粮食与食品工业, 2011,18(1):56-58,61.
[19] 马翔龙, 郭党, 李小东, 等. 玉米杂交种产量相关性状灰色关联度分析及品种评价筛选探讨. 山西农业科学, 2012,40(6):585-589,595.
[20] 张林, 张宝石, 王霞, 等. 玉米收获期籽粒含水量与主要农艺性状相关分析. 东北农业大学学报, 2009,40(10):9-12.
[1] Wang Qingbin, Nie Zhentian, Lu Jiechun, Peng Chun’e, Zhang Min, Meng Hui, Liu Zhiguo, Geng Quanzheng. Effects of Paecilomyces variotii Extract on Yield and Nitrogen Utilization of Summer Maize [J]. Crops, 2021, 37(4): 166-171.
[2] Guo Qiang, Ma Wenqing, Qin Changxian, Shi Zesheng, Peng Chong, Bi Dejin, He Hongliang, Liang Yongjian, Tang Liqiu. Comprehensive Evaluation of New Sugarcane Clones by DTOPSIS Method [J]. Crops, 2021, 37(4): 32-37.
[3] Tao Zhiqiang, Yan Peng, Zhang Xuepeng. Preliminary Study on the Adaptation of Photosynthetic Characteristics to High Temperature at Grain Filling Stages in Different Eras Maize Varieties [J]. Crops, 2021, 37(4): 73-79.
[4] Liu Tianhao, Zhang Yifei, Wang Huaipeng, Yang Kejun, Zhang Jinsong, Sun Yishan, Xiao Shanshan, Xu Rongqiong, Du Jiarui, Li Jiayu, Peng Cheng, Wang Baosheng. Regulating Effects of Foliar Spraying Silicon Fertilizer on Dry Matter Accumulation and Translocation, Grain Yield and Quality of Maize in Cold Region [J]. Crops, 2021, 37(4): 112-117.
[5] Liang Qian, Wu Qingshan, Ge Junzhu, Wu Xidong, Yang Yong’an, Hou Haipeng, Zhang Yao, Ma Zhiqi. Effects of Sowing Date on Rain-Fed Summer Maize Yield Formation and Resource Utilization in North China Plain [J]. Crops, 2021, 37(4): 136-143.
[6] Li Zilin, Lu Yachun, Zhao Leifeng, Fan Dongsheng, Wei Zhong, Zhou Wenliang, Huang Liguang, Huang Yang, Huang Jingpeng, Gu Xinquan, Nian Fuzhao. Comprehensive Evaluation of the Suitability of Tobacco Planting Soil Fertility in Jingxi City [J]. Crops, 2021, 37(3): 155-160.
[7] Qu Xiangchun, Wang Nai, Shi Guishan, Yu Miao, Li Haiqing, Gao Yue, Xu Ning, Chen Bingru. Application in Similarity-Difference Analysis Method on Evaluation of Grain Sorghum Hybrids [J]. Crops, 2021, 37(3): 46-50.
[8] Gao Peng, Guo Meijun, Yang Xuefang, Dong Shuqi, Wen Yinyuan, Guo Pingyi, Yuan Xiangyang. Responses of Photosynthetic Fluorescence Parameters in Foxtail Millet and Maize Leaves under Nicosulfuron Stress [J]. Crops, 2021, 37(3): 70-77.
[9] Liu Jianzhao, Yuan Jingchao, Liang Yao, He Yu, Zhang Shuimei, Shi Haipeng, Cai Hongguang, Ren Jun. Analysis of Field Verification and Benefit on Full Maize Straw Returning with Deep Plowing Mode [J]. Crops, 2021, 37(2): 135-139.
[10] Li Zhongnan, Wang Yueren, Wu Shenghui, Liu Liwei, Qu Haitao, Sun Zhenyu, Li Guangfa. Preliminary Study on Inheritance of Haploid Natural Double Pollen Seeding Ability in Maize [J]. Crops, 2021, 37(2): 57-61.
[11] Zhang Xuepeng, Li Teng, Wang Biao, Liu Qing, Liu Hanyu, Tao Zhiqiang, Sui Peng. Study on High Temperature Stress Threshold of Maize Leaves [J]. Crops, 2021, 37(2): 62-70.
[12] Li Ruijie, Yan Peng, Wang Qingyan, Xu Yanli, Lu Lin, Dong Zhiqiang, Zhang Fenglu. Effects of 5-Aminolevulinic Acid and Ethephon on Photosynthetic Physiology of Leaves and Yield of Spring Maize in Northeast China [J]. Crops, 2021, 37(1): 135-142.
[13] Liu Jiamin, Wang Yang, Chu Xu, Qi Xin, Wang Manman, Zhao Ya'nan, Ye Youliang, Huang Yufang. Effects of Planting Density and Nitrogen Application Rate on Annual Yield and Nitrogen Use Efficiency of Wheat-Maize Rotation System [J]. Crops, 2021, 37(1): 143-149.
[14] Liu Yan, Gong Liang, Xing Yuehua, Bao Hongjing. Study on the Optimization of Organic-Inorganic Fertilization Model for Maize Based on Orthogonal Design [J]. Crops, 2021, 37(1): 168-174.
[15] Zhou Qilong. Grey Relational Grade Evaluation of 19 Oat Varieties Introduced in Ali of Tibet [J]. Crops, 2021, 37(1): 26-31.
Viewed
Full text


Abstract

Cited
  Shared   
  Discussed   
No Suggested Reading articles found!