Crops ›› 2018, Vol. 34 ›› Issue (5): 40-44.doi: 10.16035/j.issn.1001-7283.2018.05.007

Previous Articles     Next Articles

Analysis of Stability and Adaptability of Winter Wheat Varieties in the Regional Trials of the Northern Wheat Region of China

Wang Hanxia,Shan Fuhua,Tian Liping,Ma Qiaoyun,Zhao Changping,Zhang Fengting   

  1. Beijing Academy of Agriculture and Forestry Sciences/Beijing Engineering and Technique Research Center for Hybrid Wheat, Beijing 100097, China
  • Received:2018-04-23 Revised:2018-08-17 Online:2018-10-15 Published:2018-10-12
  • Contact: Fengting Zhang

RichHTML

8

PDF (PC)

216

Abstract:

To study the yield potential and stability of winter wheat varieties in regional trials, the data of grain yield were collected from irrigated land group of winter wheat varieties regional test in the Northern Winter Region of China during 2014-2015 cropping season and analyzed by additive main effects and multiplication interaction (AMMI) model. The results could explain clearly the genotype, environment and interaction effect of genotype by environment (G×E) of wheat yield. The Nongda 3486 and Jingnong 12-79 showed the best stability, followed by Keyi 4174, Chang 6794 and Zhongmai 93, whereas Hangmai 109, Jintai 102 and Zhongxin 7198. Wuqing, Yuci, Alaer, Zunhua and Tunyu had the best resolution, while Gu'an, Luanxian, Shunyi of Beijing, Changping of Beijing were of lower resolution. The combination of AMMI biplot and stable parameters is intuitive and accurate for evaluating the stability and adaptability of winter wheat varieties in regional trial.

Key words: AMMI model, Winter wheat, Regional trial, Stability, Adaptability

Table 1

Codes and yields of varieties and sites"

编号Code 品种(系)/地点Variety (line)/Site 产量Yield (kg/hm2)
V1 京农12-79 8 386.696
V2 农大3486 8 427.004
V3 科遗4174 7 759.475
V4 航2566 8 264.429
V5 中麦93 8 060.883
V6 航麦109 8 023.096
V7 长6794 7 847.296
V8 晋太102 7 082.863
V9 众信7198 7 688.358
V10 (CK) 中麦175 7 815.550
E1 北京昌平 8 632.270
E2 北京顺义 7 251.425
E3 河北保定 6 901.085
E4 河北遵化 7 028.770
E5 河北滦县 7 306.625
E6 河北固安 9 233.355
E7 山西屯玉 8 826.450
E8 山西榆次 6 681.750
E9 山西介休 7 052.950
E10 新疆阿拉尔 9 310.985
E11 天津宝坻 9 362.895
E12 天津武清 7 638.220

Table 2

Combined analysis of variance of the yield"

变异来源Source of variation df SS MS F P
总变异Total variation 359 534 194 764.34 1 488 007.70 - -
处理Treatment 119 513 215 271.13 4 312 733.37 49.34 0.0001
基因型Genotype 9 51 046 735.63 5 671 859.51 64.88 0.0001
环境Environment 11 362 636 951.30 32 966 995.57 377.13 0.0001
基因型×环境交互作用G×E interaction 99 99 531 584.20 1 005 369.54 11.50 0.0001
误差Error 240 20 979 493.22 87 414.56 - -

Table 3

Comparison between linear regression analysis and AMMI model in wheat regional trials"

模型
Model		 变异来源
Source of variation		 df SS F P 占互作平方和百分比(%)
Percentage of G×E
线性回归Linearregression 联合回归United regression 1 66 107.00 0.76 - 0.07
基因型回归Genotype regression 8 4 087 617.89 5.85 0.0001 4.11
环境回归Environment regression 10 21 176 499.50 24.23 0.0001 21.28
残差Residual 80 74 201 359.80 - - 74.54
AMMI模型AMMI model IPCA1 19 51 722 434.68 6.35 0.0001 51.97
IPCA2 17 16 930 737.91 2.32 0.0027 17.01
IPCA3 15 10 291 945.47 1.60 - 10.34
残差Residual 48 20 586 466.14 - - 20.68

Fig.1

AMMI biplot between averaged yield and environments and varieties (lines) "

Fig.2

AMMI biplot between varieties (lines) and environment (IPCA1 and IPCA2)"

Table 4

Parameter of stability of varieties (lines) and environments"

变量Variable IPCA1 IPCA2 De 变量Variable IPCA1 IPCA2 Dg
V1 -1.8958 2.7265 3.3208 E1 -7.6516 10.5916 13.0663
V2 0.4491 0.5075 0.6777 E2 -2.1702 9.0817 9.3374
V3 4.9879 4.6747 6.8361 E3 13.2894 -15.1040 20.1181
V4 26.0995 -2.5683 26.2256 E4 -1.4525 -20.2987 20.3506
V5 -2.5333 12.1800 12.4407 E5 5.1066 -5.5336 7.5298
V6 18.8603 30.1119 35.5308 E6 -0.7144 -1.9717 2.0971
V7 -8.7016 0.8185 8.7400 E7 -11.5653 -16.6191 20.2472
V8 -42.2024 -7.0073 42.7802 E8 -38.7882 15.0362 41.6006
V9 27.0778 -34.4303 43.8024 E9 -14.3418 11.5153 18.3926
V10 -22.1416 -7.0131 23.2257 E10 16.9895 19.4828 25.8500
E11 -0.5432 -18.4644 18.4724
E12 41.8418 12.2839 43.6077
[1] 刘兆晔, 于经川, 孙晓辉 , 等. 7个小麦品种(系)高产稳产性分析. 山东农业科学, 2012,44(4):24-25,35.
[2] 穆培源, 庄丽, 张吉贞 , 等. 作物品种稳定性分析方法的研究进展. 新疆农业科学, 2003,40(3):142-144.
[3] 吴元奇, 潘光堂, 荣廷昭 . 作物稳定性研究进展. 四川农业大学学报, 2005,23(4):482-489.
[4] 聂迎彬, 穆培源, 桑伟 , 等. AMMI模型和GGE双标图法在新疆冬小麦区域试验产量分析上的应用. 新疆农业科学, 2012,49(9):1569-1575.
[5] 赵洋, 郑桂萍, 张文秀 , 等. 利用AMMI模型分析寒地水稻产量的基因型与环境互作关系. 江苏农业科学, 2015,43(4):84-86.
[6] Gauch H G . Statistical Analysis of Regional Yield Trials:AMMI Analysis of Factorial Designs. Elsevier, Amsterdam:Elsevier, 1992.
[7] Sabaghnia N, Sabaghpour S, Dehghani H . The use of an AMMI model and its parameters to analyse yield stability in multi-environment trials. Journal of Agricultural Science, 2008,146:571-581.
[8] 包奇军 . AMMI模型在啤酒大麦区域试验中的应用. 作物杂志, 2012(2):130-134.
[9] 宁东贤, 赵玉坤, 闫翠萍 , 等. 山西省南部花生品种产量稳定性的模型分析及评价. 作物杂志, 2017(3):39-43.
[10] 唐启义, 冯明光 . DPS数据处理系统. 北京: 科学出版社, 2006: 484-492.
[11] 李亚杰, 范士杰, 张俊莲 , 等. AMMI模型在马铃薯产量及农艺性状分析中的应用. 干旱地区农业研究, 2013,31(3):48-59.
[12] 王磊 . AMMI模型及其在作物区试数据分析中的应用. 应用基础工程科学学报, 1997,5(1):37-46.
[13] 伍玲, 朱华中 . 小麦品种区域试验精确度及精度分析. 西南农业学报, 2002,15(2):13-14.
[14] 姚霞, 李伟, 颜泽洪 , 等. AMMI模型在小麦区域试验产量组成性状分析中的应用. 麦类作物学报, 2005,25(6):103-107.
[15] 陈浪, 覃成, 罗希榕 , 等. 基于AMMI模型的区域试验玉米新品种稳定性和适应性评价. 农技服务, 2011,28(4):411-413,424.
[1] Wu Ruixiang,Yang Jianchun,Wang Liqin,Guo Xiujuan. Evaluation of the Adaptability of Flax Drought Resistance Based on Multiple Statistics Analysis [J]. Crops, 2018, 34(5): 10-16.
[2] An Xia,Zhang Haijun,Jiang Fangshan,Lianjie Lü,Chen Jun. Effects of Different Sowing Dates and Sowing Densities on the Population Structure and Yield of Two Spike Type Winter Wheats [J]. Crops, 2018, 34(5): 132-136.
[3] Zheng Wang,Zhaobo Chen,Shengquan Zhang,Liping Ren,Xinhuan Gao,Zhijie Ye,Fengting Zhang. Feasibility Analysis of BS Series Hybrid Wheat Seed Production in Weinan of Shaanxi Province [J]. Crops, 2018, 34(3): 174-179.
[4] Shaohui Huang,Yunma Yang,Ketong Liu,Yanming Sun,Junfang Yang,Liangliang Jia. Yield Potential, Yield Gap and Nitrogen Use Efficiency Gap of Winter Wheat in Hebei Province [J]. Crops, 2018, 34(2): 118-122.
[5] Min Song,Haipeng Zhang,Xingtao Lu,Cuixia Wu,Yong Zhang. Control Effect of Six Soil-Applied Herbicides on Lamium amplexicaule L. in Winter Wheat Field [J]. Crops, 2018, 34(2): 161-165.
[6] Songtao Liu,Guo Liu,Tinashe Zenda,Hongyu Jin,Xuan Wang,Huijun Duan. Screening of High Yield and Stable Varieties of Summer Maize in Different Ecological of Hebei Province [J]. Crops, 2018, 34(2): 56-60.
[7] Ruiqi Ma,Zhen Qi,Xuhong Chang,Demei Wang,Zhiqiang Tao,Yushuang Yang,Jinfeng Feng,Min Sun,Guangcai Zhao. Regulation Effects of Growth Regulators on Plant Characters, Yield and Quality of Winter Wheat [J]. Crops, 2018, 34(1): 133-140.
[8] Jianghui Cui,Fuzhu Cui,Jianfu Xue,Jianping Hao,Tianqing Du,Longxiang Sun. Effects of Fertilizer Reduction on Distribution and Stability of Soil Aggregates Based on Wheat-Sorghum System [J]. Crops, 2018, 34(1): 126-132.
[9] Jiachen Cao,Youfei Zheng,Hui Zhao,Jingxin Xu. Influence of Open-Top Chamber on Growth and Yield of Winter Wheat [J]. Crops, 2018, 34(1): 88-95.
[10] Shaohui Huang,Junfang Yang,Liangliang Jia,Yunma Yang,Wenfang Yang,Yanming Sun. Effects of Slow-Release Urea Formaldehyde on Yield of Winter Wheat and the Distribution of Nitrate Nitrogen in Soil [J]. Crops, 2017, 33(3): 110-114.
[11] Dongxian Ning,Yukun Zhao,Cuiping Yan,Xiuli Yang,Junhong Xiao,Liping Yang. Analysis and Evaluation of Different Models for Yield Stability of Peanut Cultivars in Southern Shanxi [J]. Crops, 2017, 33(3): 39-43.
[12] Lijie Liu,Dongxiang Zhang,Zhongmin Jin,Lidong Lin,Yanbo Ren,Jingtong Zhao,Jing Cang. Effects of Exogenous Salicylic Acid on Cell Ultrastructure of Winter Wheat under Cold Stress in Frigid Region [J]. Crops, 2017, 33(3): 60-68.
[13] Lianjie Xie,Nana Li,Yanting Pei,Jianxia Song,Lei Zhao,Zhiqiang Li,Hanfeng Ding. Absorption Characteristics of Soil Mineral Elements by Main Winter Wheat Varieties in Shandong Province in the Past 60 Years [J]. Crops, 2017, 33(1): 56-60.
[14] Lianxi Wang,Chang Liu,Qi Li,Dongli Wu,Qing Wang,Wei Cheng. The Northern Boundary Variation of Winter Wheat in Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei under Climate Warming [J]. Crops, 2017, 33(1): 61-67.
[15] Junying Wang,Jihong Zhou,Fanyu Meng,Sishuai Mao,Jianguo Yang,Jinliang Zhang,Yajia Liu,Xiaolong Li. Research and Application on System of Water-Saving, Fertilizer-Saving, Pesticide-Saving and Simplified Technology of Winter Wheat in Beijing [J]. Crops, 2016, 32(6): 99-106.
Viewed
Full text


Abstract

Cited
  Shared   
  Discussed   
[1] Guangcai Zhao,Xuhong Chang,Demei Wang,Zhiqiang Tao,Yanjie Wang,Yushuang Yang,Yingjie Zhu. General Situation and Development of Wheat Production[J]. Crops, 2018, 34(4): 1 -7 .
[2] Baoquan Quan,Dongmei Bai,Yuexia Tian,Yunyun Xue. Effects of Different Leaf-Peg Ratio on Photosynthesis and Yield of Peanut[J]. Crops, 2018, 34(4): 102 -105 .
[3] Xuefang Huang,Mingjing Huang,Huatao Liu,Cong Zhao,Juanling Wang. Effects of Annual Precipitation and Population Density on Tiller-Earing and Yield of Zhangzagu 5 under Film Mulching and Hole Sowing[J]. Crops, 2018, 34(4): 106 -113 .
[4] Wenhui Huang, Hui Wang, Desheng Mei. Research Progress on Lodging Resistance of Crops[J]. Crops, 2018, 34(4): 13 -19 .
[5] Yun Zhao,Cailong Xu,Xu Yang,Suzhen Li,Jing Zhou,Jicun Li,Tianfu Han,Cunxiang Wu. Effects of Sowing Methods on Seedling Stand and Production Profit of Summer Soybean under Wheat-Soybean System[J]. Crops, 2018, 34(4): 114 -120 .
[6] Mei Lu,Min Sun,Aixia Ren,Miaomiao Lei,Lingzhu Xue,Zhiqiang Gao. Effects of Spraying Foliar Fertilizers on Dryland Wheat Growth and the Correlation with Yield Formation[J]. Crops, 2018, 34(4): 121 -125 .
[7] Xiaofei Wang,Haijun Xu,Mengqiao Guo,Yu Xiao,Xinyu Cheng,Shuxia Liu,Xiangjun Guan,Yaokun Wu,Weihua Zhao,Guojiang Wei. Effects of Sowing Date, Density and Fertilizer Utilization Rate on the Yield of Oilseed Perilla frutescens in Cold Area[J]. Crops, 2018, 34(4): 126 -130 .
[8] Pengjin Zhu,Xinhua Pang,Chun Liang,Qinliang Tan,Lin Yan,Quanguang Zhou,Kewei Ou. Effects of Cold Stress on Reactive Oxygen Metabolism and Antioxidant Enzyme Activities of Sugarcane Seedlings[J]. Crops, 2018, 34(4): 131 -137 .
[9] Jie Gao,Qingfeng Li,Qiu Peng,Xiaoyan Jiao,Jinsong Wang. Effects of Different Nutrient Combinations on Plant Production and Nitrogen, Phosphorus and Potassium Utilization Characteristics in Waxy Sorghum[J]. Crops, 2018, 34(4): 138 -142 .
[10] Na Shang,Zhongxu Yang,Qiuzhi Li,Huihui Yin,Shihong Wang,Haitao Li,Tong Li,Han Zhang. Response of Cotton with Vegetative Branches to Plant Density in the Western of Shandong Province[J]. Crops, 2018, 34(4): 143 -148 .